Wednesday, January 7, 2026

Can't Go Back to Herod: An Epiphany Sermon

 


This is the first time we've done an Epiphany service at St. Barnabas since I've been there. Seems odd that we haven't celebrated this major feast before, but with me being part-time, living 80 miles away,  and no one insisting, we just haven't. But we did this year, chalking our door with "20+C-M-B-26."  We are not seeing any children in church right now, so there was no pageant as is sometimes a custom. But we did sing, "We Three Kings" which was the perfect starting point for this sermon...and had an important lesson for us in this time of authoritarianism.
See what you think.

Text: Matthew 2:1-12

+++

John Henry Hopkins lyrics to “We Three Kings” have set the stage in our imaginations for centuries about these three visitors from the East who followed a star to find the Christ child in Bethlehem.

Hopkins hymn has told us they were kings…and in the stanzas…he’s given each of them back stories.

And tradition has assigned them names based upon the gifts they brought...the gold, frankincense, and myrrh.

We assume there are three of them because there are three gifts.

But maybe there were two….or could there have been more?

Nah…that wouldn’t work.

That would totally mess up the manger scenes.

But then…our traditional manger scenes have already gone off track from the Gospel story.

There is no crib of hay in Matthew’s story.

In fact…these foreign magi enter a “house” to find Mary and “the child.”

And…given the account that happens a few verses later in this chapter of Herod’s jealous rage that leads to the deaths of Jewish boys in Bethlehem who are two years old…we get the idea that these magi have been following that star for a while.

 These “magi”…or as we have translated it…these “wise men” are “from the East.”

They may have been Zoroastrians…an Eastern religion of the Persian Empire…a monotheistic belief system that teaches ethical living and a constant struggle between good and evil.

 They may have been either astrologers or magicians.

And they are on a journey… a euphemism often used when one is talking about seeking God.

They’re following a star…chasing after this sign in the sky…hoping to find a child born King of the Jews…so that they might pay him homage.

In his book “Brightest and Best: A Companion to the Lesser Feasts and Fasts”…Episcopal chaplain Sam Portaro suggests that if these magi were magicians…they may have been something like traveling entertainers.

Portaro wonders how wise they might have been…since they went to Herod to ask where to find this child called “King of the Jews”…a title that Herod proudly had accepted for himself when the Roman Emperor Augustus conferred it on him.

Any wise person would have known better than to tell Herod about this child king given his reputation for killing his rivals.

Maybe they hadn’t fully discerned the politics of the region.

Maybe they were so fixated on following the star that they hadn’t paid attention to the way Herod shifted uneasily when they mentioned they were looking for another king of the Jews.

And Herod…regaining his composure…and in a manner we might see in a classic Disney villain…requests that these wise men serve as envoys for him…

“Oh…please do come back and tell me where I might find this child in Bethlehem so that I…too…may pay homage to him.”

It’s interesting that “paying homage” gets repeated here.

To “pay homage” suggests something more than a simple nod of the head and a “greetings and salutations.”

“Paying homage” is to prostrate oneself…kneel or lay down before an authority.

Herod said he wanted to pay homage to the Christ child…and he should have wanted to do that.

It’s what we say in our prayers of the people…that we look for leaders who will turn away from greed and a lust for power…and to govern from a place of justice and compassion.

To be like the king as described in Psalm 72…

“That he may rule your people righteously…and the poor with justice.” (72:2)

But…of course…he wasn’t sincere.

After all…he is not on a journey.

So when the wise men arrive…we hear that they were overwhelmed with joy.

And when they entered the house…and saw the child with Mary…they paid him homage.

These Zoroastrian strangers immediately see what the shepherds from Luke’s Gospel had seen earlier.

And like those shepherds…they too were amazed…and filled with wonder and joy.

And it brought them to their knees…lying face down on the floor.

Only then…did they remember to break out the gold…the frankincense…and the myrrh.

It seems the most important gift they offered was not the valuable “things” that they brought along in their treasure chest.

The primary gift was themselves….their bodies…and their desire to seek and find what this wonderous star was beckoning them to discover an incarnation of God’s Love into the world.

This was their epiphany…that moment of “a-ha”….that brought them to Bethlehem.

They have met God…the God that they recognize…the Holy One of Justice and Mercy.

They have found God in this Jewish child.

And God has shattered barriers between cultures.

God has demonstrated that Divine Love is able to reach past all borders…all religions…all labels…and differences to touch us so deeply as to overwhelm us with joy.

If these men weren’t wise before their journey…they are leaving greatly changed.

No wonder their dream told them to travel back a different way.

They are no longer able to go back toward the way of Herod…that world of domination and fear…and the need to have power over others.

They’ve been changed.

The same can be true for us too.

We…too…can travel a different road.

God’s desire for us is not about wealth…or titles…or our precious metals…or other expensive gifts.

The only thing God has ever needed from us is our willingness to open our hearts to God…and allow Love to transform us.

God’s intent is to set us on a road away from the self-centered path that seeks to control others and assert our dominance over other people.

The thing we must do is bring ourselves…our wise and foolish…our perfectly imperfect selves…to God…and be willing to be wowed and changed.

In the name of our One Holy and Undivided Trinity.

 

 


No comments: