One of my favorite scenes in the Britsh comedy "Absolutely Fabulous" is when Edina is in court faces all kinds of charges violating traffic laws. She's delivering one of her many pointless, silly rants when the judge interrupts her and says, "Is there a point to all of this?"
Edina looks at her wrist, taps it meaningfully, and says, "Yes. Why oh why do we pay taxes, hmm?!"
I've used that line on April 15th ever since!
Taxes were on the docket for this Sunday's lectionary reading. See what you think of what I had to say.
Matt 22: 15-22
+++
I feel pretty confident in saying that nobody likes to pay taxes. I know I certainly don’t enjoy the exercise of putting together the documentation to figure out what I owe the I-R-S every April.
And those are just the income taxes. But as we all know…we pay taxes all the time…when we buy gas or groceries.
These
days…those taxes are only adding to the hefty cost of everything.
The
taxes our Biblical ancestors were expected to pay were burdensome for a lot of
reasons.
For
starters….this is a tax on an occupied people…to pay for the army that is in
place to keep them in line.
And
if you remember your colonial history…the British King did the same thing to
those living in the colonies…which led to a war of Independence.
Not
only did Rome expect the occupied Jewish population to pay this “Tribute tax”
per male person…the Empire taxed the land and their agricultural
produce…grapes…figs…olives and such.
Adding
to the insult of all of this…to pay the tax…the Jews had to go to the Temple
and exchange their Jewish coinage…which lacked any facial image… for the Roman
currency in order to pay the tax.
The
Roman coins had the face of Caesar Tiberius…and an inscription about the
Emperor’s divinity emblazoned along the bottom.
All
of which was offensive to the Jewish laws about making graven images and such.
And
if that wasn’t bad enough…the Roman officials weren’t the ones collecting the
taxes. They pressed local Jews to be the bad guys.
And
those tax collectors were notorious for adding their own extra charge…kind of
like a built-in tip…for doing Rome’s dirty work.
So
the Jewish population really hated this “tribute tax.”
And
those who saw Jesus as a threat to their status thought they’d found the
perfect way to discredit him.
By
making him answer questions about a coin.
A
coin that represented a day’s wages for the average person.
Now…here’s
the funny thing about this coin.
The
two groups that approach Jesus had two very different views about this
particular coin.
On
the one hand…the Herodians…fans of the Herod family…who were only nominally
Jewish in their practices…didn’t have a problem with this money.
The
Pharisees…on the other hand…would have been very bothered by everything this
coin symbolized…the oppression and the hardships the Romans heaped upon the
Jews…not to mention having the face of the current emperor and declaring him a
“High Priest” on the inscription.
Still…
they were willing to look past all of this to join with this other group in a
game of “Gotcha” with Jesus.
And
just in the way Jesus flipped over tables in the Temple…he put his aikido-like
rhetorical skills to work to not only side-step their gotcha question…but to
embarrass them.
Aikido
is a type of Japanese martial arts that doesn’t aim to pummel an opponent into
submission.
But
rather it uses the opponent’s own energy and movements to redirect them and
avoid danger.
So
here come these representatives of the Pharisees and the Herodians…heaping
empty praise for Jesus on him…”you show no partiality…you teach the way of
God…”
And
then they hit him with their clever gotcha question: “Is it lawful to pay taxes
to the Emperor?”
Now…there’s
a crowd around them…made up of Jews from Jerusalem. And if Jesus says “yes,
it’s lawful”…this rotten Tribute Tax is lawful…then he’ll be seen as a
collaborator with the Roman oppressor. If he says, “No” then he could be
arrested for sedition.
But
Jesus instead says, “Show me the coin in your pocket.”
And
they pull out a denarii….with the Emperor’s face…a graven image.
Already…the
crowd starts to stir with discomfort….asking amongst themselves what type of
Pharisee would have that offensive coin on their person?!
Then
Jesus completes his take down of his opponents with a simple declarative
statement:
“This coin has Caesar’s face on it. So clearly it must belong to Caesar. Give
it back to him. And give back to God what has the image of God.”
And
what bears the likeness of God?
All
things…all living creatures…you and me.
Some
would like to cast this passage as Jesus establishing a separation of church
and state.
But
what he’s saying is something that is much more demanding of us.
It’s
not that we should live our lives in these separate silos…state over
here…church over there.
But
we should live in a way that recognizes the limitations of the state…and the
powers of the state…and to see that God actually occupies and lays claim to
more than mere slogans and faces on coins.
Because
we are the bearers of God’s image…the Imago Dei.
And
as Senator Raphael Warnock has said…”Dei” is spelled D-E-I.
And
truly it is our D-E-I…our diversity…equity…and inclusion…that has made the
church and the whole community a better and more vibrant place.
It
is our differences and variety of characteristics that help us to keep a
broader view of the world as we work to make a society where everyone can have
a shot at making a life.
Because
we are made in God’s image…and because we see the value of all members playing
a role in society…we have the opportunity to speak up when we become aware that
our government is acting in ways that conflict with the will of God…failing to
love the neighbor…show mercy to the stranger…and having compassion for those
who are struggling.
This
leads us…as members of Christ’s Body…to follow where Jesus is pointing in the
way he turned the question back on his opponents.
Because
the issue isn’t so much whether it’s “legal” to pay taxes.
The
question for us is how are our tax dollars spent?
Does
that money go toward improving the lives of those living in our community?
Or
are these dollars being used to tear us apart…and separate us from each other?
When
our money is stamped with the word “Liberty” do we have a country where we use
our freedom to build people up…respect everyone’s dignity…and work toward a
land where all can enjoy a more just society?
These
are not easy questions for any of us to answer.
But
the expectation of us who bear the image of God is to engage in this
work…whether we ever see it finally accomplished or not.
And
this is why we have elections…why we vote for people to represent us.
We
look to them to carry our hopes and dreams into a lived reality.
It’s
the reason we pray for those in elected leadership positions that they pay
attention to what’s happening…seek answers…and do their best to make policies
that use our financial resources wisely.
We
have been given the responsibility to give back to God what is God’s.
May
we take that stewardship seriously…and do our part to care for the planet as
well as each other.
In
the name of our One Holy and Undivided Trinity.

No comments:
Post a Comment